Housing Project Suffers Setback
Nov 17, 2026 04:00PM ● By Keith Burbank
A map showing the location of the Summer Villas at Sheldon Road project. Photo courtesy of the city of Elk Grove
ELK GROVE, CA (MPG) - A controversial housing development here suffered another setback Nov. 5.
Planning commissioners voted 4-1 to recommend the Summer Villas at Sheldon Road project for denial at their Nov. 5 meeting. That recommendation was sent to the City Council, which has yet to take up the proposal. Commissioner Juan Fernandez was the dissenting vote.
“As a planning commissioner, we have to look at the needs of the city and the community at large,” Fernandez said at the meeting.
The project caters to seniors, Fernandez said, and his mother-in-law could have moved into one of the homes after she was widowed. She had to leave 5 acres off Bradshaw, he said.
The recommendation for denial comes following an earlier recommendation by city staff to deny the changes needed to build the project.
“I’m pleased with the Planning Commission outcome,” said former Planning Commissioner George Murphey, who has been advocating against the project.
Murphey is the chairperson for the Sheldon Community Association, he said. The association represents members on issues from Bradshaw Road, north and south to Bond and Calvine roads, east and south to the city limits, including the Sheldon Business District, according to the website for Save Rural Elk Grove.
Save Rural Elk Grove is “dedicated to transparency regarding the Summer Villas proposal and land use changes in the Sheldon area of Elk Grove,” according to its website.
Murphey thinks the project would set a precedent, which he said commissioners acknowledged at the meeting. It would likely have impacts on policies for the Rural Area such as the roads policy and a prohibition on urban services like sewer service, Murphey said.
He is unsure how the City Council will vote on the project, which has yet to be placed on a public agenda.
“We were disappointed by the Planning Commission's 4–1 recommendation to deny the project, but we appreciated the thoughtful discussion about housing choices for Elk Grove seniors and the future of the Rural Area,” developer Bryan Wilson told the Elk Grove Citizen Nov. 16.
The ability to afford housing is a concern for Elk Grove residents, Wilson added.
“Summer Villas would offer seniors a single story, age restricted option that is more attainable than the million-dollar estate style properties that are the likely alternative for this land,” Wilson said. “It would also give seniors who want to downsize a chance to stay near their families and community, while potentially making their existing homes available to growing families.”
The City Council has the final say on the project.
“We hope its members will weigh the needs of the entire city, including the need for more housing choices for seniors,” Wilson said.

















